Open House
Sun, Nov 8 · 11:00AM–1:00PM
Open House
Sun, Nov 8 · 11:00AM–1:00PM
264 Cumberland Street 5
$1,989,000
MLS# RLS20124108 · Fort Greene
Listed November 5, 2026 · New today
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,558 Sq.Ft.
About This Property
Historic Character Meets Modern Living in the Heart of Fort Greene. Nestled along one of Fort Greene’s most picturesque, tree-lined blocks, this expansive three-bedroom, two-bathroom duplex offers a rare combination of historic architectural charm, thoughtfully updated interiors, and a private garden oasis. Located within The Sanctuary Condominium, a landmarked neo-Gothic church originally built in 1915 and converted into intimate condominium residences in 2008, this 1,558-square-foot home offers a distinctive living experience in one of Brooklyn’s most beloved neighborhoods.
The home's spacious and versatile layout unfolds across two levels, offering generous proportions, large windwos, and an effortless flow between indoor and outdoor living.
On the main level, an inviting living and dining area provides ample room for entertaining, relaxing, and everyday living. The open chef’s kitchen features elegant Carrara marble countertops and a substantial island, complemented by dark wood cabinetry, Bosch stainless steel appliances, and a new Fisher & Paykel refrigerator. Whether hosting friends for dinner or enjoying a quiet morning at home, the open layout creates a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
One of the home's most compelling features is its private garden, a peaceful retreat from the energy of the city. Accessible from both levels of the duplex, this outdoor sanctuary features built-in wood bench seating and provides an idyllic setting for alfresco dining, gardening, entertaining, or simply unwinding beneath the trees.
The three bedrooms offer flexibility for a variety of lifestyles, with ample space for a home office, guest accommodations, or growing household. The primary suite was fully renovated in 2022 and features architect-designed custom built-in closets, providing both beauty and exceptional functionality.
Two full bathrooms offer a refined blend of materials and finishes. The upstairs bathroom features Galala beige marble, mosaic tile flooring, and a deep soaking tub, while the beautifully renovated downstairs bathroom showcases Carrara marble mosaics, terracotta tile flooring, and updated fixtures.
Additional highlights include hardwood floors on the upper level, central HVAC with dual-zone climate control updated in 2022, an in-unit LG washer and dryer installed in 2025, and an abundance of storage, including generous closets and extensive under-stair storage.
The Sanctuary is a pet-friendly boutique condominium that blends the character of its historic origins with the comforts of contemporary Brooklyn living. Recent building improvements include a new roof completed in 2023–2024.
The location is quintessential Fort Greene. Just moments from Fort Greene Park, the neighborhood's celebrated restaurants, independent boutiques, cafés, and cultural destinations, residents enjoy an exceptional combination of community and convenience. BAM, the Brooklyn Flea, Whole Foods, and Barclays Center are all nearby, while convenient access to the C and G subway lines, Atlantic Terminal, and the LIRR makes commuting throughout the city and beyond effortless.
With its distinctive history, generous proportions, beautifully updated interiors, and coveted private outdoor space, 264 Cumberland Street, Residence 5 offers a rare opportunity to enjoy the very best of Fort Greene living.
Agent's Note
From Curtis Bain. Details about the apartment are drawn from the listing information provided through RLS by Compass.
The main level's open kitchen runs straight into the living and dining area, so cooking and hosting share one room. That suits dinner with friends, and nobody is cut off from the table, though there's less separation between the stove and the sofa. Carrara marble countertops top a large island, with dark wood cabinets, Bosch stainless steel appliances and a new Fisher & Paykel refrigerator.
The home runs across two levels, so a staircase connects the main living area to the upper floor. In return you get a primary suite that was fully renovated in 2022, with architect-designed custom built-in closets. Generous closets and extensive under-stair storage add to the space, which matters in a three-bedroom home.
Access to the private garden from both levels is the detail that matters most in a duplex. You can step out from the main floor or from upstairs. It has built-in wood bench seating for dining, gardening or sitting under the trees, and the listing also notes a garden view from the home.
Both bathrooms are finished in marble.
The upstairs bathroom is clad in a beige marble called Galala, sits on mosaic tile floors and includes a deep tub for soaking. The downstairs bathroom pairs Carrara marble mosaics with terracotta tile flooring. An in-unit LG washer and dryer, installed in 2025, means laundry stays at home.
The building is a pet-friendly boutique condominium housed in a neo-Gothic church built in 1915 and converted in 2008. Dual-zone central HVAC was updated in 2022, and a new roof was completed in 2023 to 2024. The location puts you near Fort Greene Park and the neighborhood's restaurants, independent boutiques and cafés.
Quick answers+
Does the apartment have in-unit laundry?
Yes. It has an in-unit LG washer and dryer, installed in 2025.
Is there private outdoor space?
Yes. The private garden is accessible from both levels of the duplex, and it is over 60 square feet, with built-in wood bench seating.
Are pets allowed?
Cats and dogs are allowed in the building.
Curtis Bain
Brown Harris Stevens
Property Features
Policies
- Cats and dogs allowed
Home features
- Washer/dryer in unit
- Central air
- Central heating
- Hardwood floors
- Garden view
- Dishwasher
- Stainless steel appliances
- Soaking tub
- Balcony
- Private outdoor space (over 60 sq ft)
- Patio
Building amenities
Outdoor space
- Garden
Estimate
Monthly Cost & Closing Costs
The rate is a placeholder, not a quote. Enter the one your lender gives you.
$11,951 / month
- Principal and interest$10,057
- Common charges$542
- Property taxes$1,352
Due at closing
- Down payment (20%)$397,800
- NYS “mansion tax” (1%)$19,890
- Mortgage recording tax (1.925%)$30,631
Not included: attorney, title insurance, lender and appraisal fees, board application and move-in fees, flip tax and prepaid items. Estimates only, based on the published New York State rates. Your attorney and lender will confirm the real figures.
Gallery
Property Photos
Listing Courtesy of Compass
This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved.