1 / 25

168 E 91ST Street

$11,950,000

MLS# RLS20125689 · Carnegie Hill

Listed November 6, 2026 · New today

5 Beds 6 Baths 7,700 Sq.Ft.

About This Property

25' TOWNHOUSE WITH CARRIAGE HOUSE

NEW TO MARKET!! A magnificent 25'-wide elevator townhouse with 13 rooms and a separate carriage house, 168 East 91st Street offers remarkable scale and a caliber of workmanship rarely seen. Following a comprehensive, no-expense-spared reconstruction, the home was entirely gutted, receiving new structural steel, plumbing, electrical and commercial-grade mechanical systems. The same extraordinary attention to detail is evident throughout its sprawling interiors where meticulously selected finishes reflect the considerable care, thought and investment behind every aspect of this home.

The garden level opens to an elegant limestone entry gallery with custom paneling and a handsome staircase to the parlor floor. A powder room and spacious home office occupy this level, while a separately accessed commercial space (vacant) offers continued retail or office use, or easy incorporation into the residence. To the rear and visible through a suite of French doors is a beautiful landscaped private, Bluestone-decked garden with a built-in Wolf grill, flanked by a glorious separate carriage house with a soaring cathedral ceiling and finished in striking vertical-grain Douglas Fir paneling. With a sleeping loft and independent heating/cooling, this retreat has many possibilities, from guest accommodations to an additional recreation space.

On the parlor level, the expansive living room features a fireplace and herringbone floors of rare imported old-growth oak which continue into a moody formal dining room sized for grand gatherings. Adjacent, the massive sundrenched eat-in kitchen overlooks the garden through a wall of windows to the south. There is an island with bar seating as well as a separate casual dining area. Custom cabinetry, a tiled backsplash and granite countertops complement a full suite of high-end appliances by Wolf, Sub-Zero, Miele and Gaggenau. A powder room completes this floor.

The third floor features a jaw-dropping den for lounging and entertaining with 12' high coffered ceilings, a wood-burning fireplace, oversized windows as well as French doors which open to an enchanting private terrace overlooking the garden and carriage house. There are two bedroom suites on this floor as well: the larger with a fireplace and en-suite full bathroom with stall shower which can also be accessed from the den, and the smaller with a charming sleeping loft and its own en-suite bathroom. A laundry room with full-size vented washer/dryer and sink completes the floor.

The fourth floor holds two king-sized bedroom suites, each with a huge and custom built-out study area, an en-suite bathroom and a large walk-in closet.

The fifth floor is devoted entirely to a luxurious primary suite: The large primary bedroom adjoins a south-facing sitting room that opens onto a glorious private terrace, all overlooking the house's glorious private garden and carriage house. On the bedroom's north side is a 15'-long windowed dressing room and a sumptuous primary bathroom with a deep soaking tub, double vanity, spa shower and enclosed water closet with toilet and bidet. A skylight bathes the bathroom in natural light, completing this beautifully appointed private sanctuary.

On the sixth floor, an enormous skylit fitness and wellness room invites sunny morning workouts and moonlit evening massages. There is also a substantial walk-in closet for additional storage and a roof terrace awaiting the next owner's finishing touch.

Thoughtful features and upgrades of this grand and gorgeous home include individually zoned heating and cooling in every room, radiant-heated floors in select areas, a sprinkler system, 16-zone Sonos audio, an all-new Crestron system and exterior security cameras, among many more carefully considered details, both seen and unseen.

168 East 91st Street is an offering of the highest caliber. Ideally situated in beloved Carnegie Hill, this one-of-a-kind home enjoys the charm of one of Manhattan's most distinguished residential neighborhoods with Central Park, the city's finest museums, cultural and educational institutions as well as an abundance of sophisticated shopping and dining all moments away.

Property Features

Policies

  • Pets allowed
  • Smoke-free

Home features

  • Washer/dryer in unit
  • Zoned cooling
  • Fireplace
  • Dishwasher
  • High ceilings
  • Walk-in closets
  • Private garden
  • Private outdoor space (over 60 sq ft)
  • Terrace

Building amenities

Services and facilities

  • Elevator
  • Green building

Estimate

Monthly Cost & Closing Costs

The rate is a placeholder, not a quote. Enter the one your lender gives you.

$64,032 / month

  • Principal and interest$60,426
  • Property taxes$3,606

Due at closing

  • Down payment (20%)$2,390,000
  • NYS “mansion tax” (3.25%)$388,375
  • Mortgage recording tax (1.925%)$184,030

Not included: attorney, title insurance, lender and appraisal fees, board application and move-in fees, flip tax and prepaid items. Estimates only, based on the published New York State rates. Your attorney and lender will confirm the real figures.

About the Building

168 E 91ST Street is a 5-story mixed-use residential in Carnegie Hill, completed in 1899 and home to 1 residential units. The most recent major alteration on record was in 2005.

The closest subway is 86 St (4, 5, 6), about a 6-minute walk. Marx Brothers Playground is roughly 9 minutes away on foot.

Compiled from NYC public records and open data.

Year Built
1899
Stories
5
Units
1
Building Type
Mixed-Use Residential

View 168 E 91ST Street building profile and all listings →

Location & Nearby

Map

Loading map…

168 E 91ST Street

Subway

  • 45686 StAbout 6 min walk
  • 696 StAbout 7 min walk
  • Q86 StAbout 8 min walk · Accessible
  • Q96 StAbout 8 min walk · Accessible

Parks

  • Marx Brothers PlaygroundAbout 9 min walk
  • Central ParkAbout 9 min walk
  • Stanley Isaacs PlaygroundAbout 10 min walk

Public schools · Elementary schools

  • P.S. 198 Isidor E. Ida StrausAbout 6 min walk
  • P.S. 77 Lower Lab SchoolAbout 6 min walk
  • P.S. 527 - East Side School for Social ActionAbout 7 min walk

Middle schools

  • East Side Middle SchoolAbout 7 min walk
  • M.S. 224 Manhattan East School for Arts & AcademicsAbout 15 min walk

High schools

  • The High School for Climate JusticeAbout 9 min walk
  • The Judith S. Kaye SchoolAbout 10 min walk

Colleges & universities

  • Icahn School of Medicine at Mount SinaiAbout 15 min walk

Museums

  • Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design MuseumAbout 8 min walk
  • National Academy of DesignAbout 9 min walk
  • Jewish MuseumAbout 9 min walk
  • Solomon R. Guggenheim MuseumAbout 9 min walk

Walking times are estimates. Schools shown are the nearest public and charter schools and are not zone assignments; a nearby school is not necessarily the one an address is zoned for. Confirm zoning with the NYC Department of Education. Sources: MTA, NYC Parks and NYC Department of City Planning open data.

The Neighborhood

About Upper East Side

Carnegie Hill is covered by our Upper East Side guide.

Manhattan's gold standard for luxury living with iconic architecture, Central Park, and Museum Mile.

Walkability

9/10

Public transit

9/10

Schools

10/10

Dining

9/10

Groceries & parks

9/10

Schools in Upper East Side

Many of NYC's most selective schools sit here, with a concentration of elite K-12 private schools, strong public feeders like PS 6 and PS 290, and easy access to top selective high schools.

Private schools in the area include The Dalton School, The Brearley School, The Chapin School, The Spence School, Nightingale-Bamford School, The Browning School.

Explore Upper East Side

Listing Courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC

Back to Home Search
RLS: Real Estate Board of New York Residential Listing Service

This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved.