557 CARLTON Avenue 1
$9,500/mo
MLS# RLS20122561 · Prospect Heights
Listed October 23, 2026 · 4 days on the market
2 Beds 2 Baths
About This Property
Experience the elegance and grandeur of classic Brooklyn brownstone living at 557 Carlton Avenue. Set across three beautifully proportioned levels of an intimate two-family residence, this expansive two-bedroom, two-bathroom triplex seamlessly blends historic architectural character, generous living spaces, and a lush private garden sanctuary in the heart of Prospect Heights.Dating to the early 20th century, the residence is a celebration of Brooklyn's architectural heritage. Exquisite original woodwork, intricate parquet and hardwood floors, soaring ceilings, elaborate crown moldings, decorative ceiling medallions, and beautifully preserved millwork create an atmosphere of timeless sophistication. Graceful archways, substantial wooden doors, and richly detailed banisters reflect the craftsmanship of a bygone era.The parlor level showcases the home's most remarkable period details, featuring two generously proportioned bedrooms positioned at the front and rear of the residence. One is distinguished by an exquisite decorative fireplace with an ornate mantel, while both offer beautiful natural light, substantial wood-trimmed doorways, and original architectural detailing.The garden level features an inviting front-facing living room and an exceptionally spacious, rear-facing eat-in kitchen designed for everyday comfort and entertaining. Highlights include stainless steel appliances, a dishwasher, custom wine storage, abundant cabinetry, and a striking wall of original wood built-ins with glass-fronted display cabinets. Beautifully patterned tile flooring adds character, while a full bathroom with a bathtub completes this level.Beyond the kitchen awaits a true urban oasis: a private landscaped garden framed by mature greenery, charming brick pavers, and thoughtfully arranged plantings. Perfect for alfresco dining, morning coffee, or quiet relaxation, this enchanting outdoor retreat offers a rare sense of tranquility in the heart of Brooklyn.The fully finished lower level provides an exceptional extension of the home's usable space, ideal for a media lounge, recreation area, home gym, or creative workspace. Built-in shelving, additional storage, an in-unit washer and dryer, and a second full bathroom with a stand-up shower complete this versatile level.Situated along one of Prospect Heights' quintessential brownstone-lined blocks, 557 Carlton Avenue offers exceptional access to Brooklyn's most celebrated destinations. Barclays Center and Atlantic Terminal are moments away, while Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, and Crown Heights offer an abundance of acclaimed restaurants, cafés, and boutiques. Prospect Park, Grand Army Plaza, the Brooklyn Museum, Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the Brooklyn Public Library's landmark Central Library are all nearby.An extraordinary combination of preserved historic detail, expansive three-level living, and an enchanting private garden, Residence 1 offers a distinctly Brooklyn living experience that is increasingly difficult to find.
Agent's Note
From Curtis Bain. Details about the apartment are drawn from the listing information provided through RLS by Douglas Elliman Real Estate.
A wall of original wood built-ins with glass-fronted display cabinets is the detail that stands out most at 557 Carlton Avenue, Unit 1, a two-bedroom triplex in Prospect Heights. It sits on the garden level, beside an eat-in kitchen that faces the rear and has stainless steel appliances, a dishwasher, custom wine storage and plenty of cabinetry. That's enough room for everyday cooking and for having people over, and the kitchen also has a bathroom close by on the same level.
The parlor level holds both bedrooms, one at the front and one at the rear.
The original woodwork, parquet and hardwood floors, crown moldings and ceiling medallions carry the period character through these rooms, and the arches and banisters show the same level of craftsmanship. You'll notice how much of it survives intact, and that matters when you're comparing a place like this with newer stock.
The lower level is fully finished and adds real usable space. Shelving and extra storage are built in, and laundry is inside the home, with a washer and dryer on this level. A second full bathroom with a stand-up shower sits here too, so it can serve as a media lounge, a home gym or a workspace without taking over the rest of the house. Having laundry on the same floor as the bath is a daily convenience you notice quickly.
Beyond the kitchen, a private landscaped garden with brick pavers and mature plantings gives you an outdoor place for meals or a quiet morning coffee. In the city, a private garden like this is an uncommon amenity, and it's worth seeing how the plantings look at the time of year you'd use it most.
Bergen St station on the 2 and 3 lines is about 6 minutes on foot, and Grand Army Plaza on the same lines is about 10 minutes away. Dean Playground is about 2 minutes on foot. Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Museum and the Brooklyn Botanic Garden are all nearby, which makes the home a good base for weekend plans.
Quick answers+
Does the apartment have in-unit laundry?
Yes. The fully finished lower level has an in-unit washer and dryer.
Is there private outdoor space?
Yes. A private landscaped garden with brick pavers and mature plantings is reached from beyond the kitchen.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does the home have?
It has two bedrooms and two full bathrooms, one on the garden level with a bathtub and one on the lower level with a stand-up shower.
Curtis Bain
Brown Harris Stevens
Property Features
Home features
- Washer/dryer in unit
- Fireplace
Gallery
Property Photos
Listing Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved.
